北京
近日，有網友反映稱，其花費30元購買的《人像攝影口袋書》存在嚴重質量問題：書中大量人像圖片疑似AI生成，且部分人物出現六根手指、六根腳趾等明顯的AI生成錯誤。
A photography guidebook published by a major Chinese press has drawn controversy after readers found that nearly half of its images were allegedly AI-generated and contained obvious anatomical errors.
anatomical /??n??t?m?k(?)l/ 解剖學的
圖源：長江云新聞
據長江云新聞1月13日報道，記者翻閱全書后發現，書中用于講解人像攝影技巧的配圖共計159張，其中為AI生成的圖片有75張，占比近50%。
這些AI生成的圖片有典型特征：人物面部細節模糊、光影過渡生硬，除了網友提及的六指、六趾等生理結構錯誤外，部分圖片還存在手部姿態扭曲等問題。
The book, titled
Portrait Photography, priced at 30 yuan, reportedly includes images showing common AI flaws such as blurred facial features, unnatural lighting, distorted hand poses, and figures with six fingers or toes.
A review of the book found that of the 159 images used to illustrate portrait photography techniques, 75, nearly half, appeared to be AI-generated rather than real photographs.
圖源：長江云新聞
該書籍的出版方人民郵電出版社客服回應稱：“經核實，該書確實存在相關質量問題，針對此類情況，我們將為消費者提供無條件退款服務。”
對于書中出現的AI人像未作標注的質疑，客服回應稱：“由于作者在提交稿件時未說明書中部分圖片為AI生成，出版社在審核過程中未能及時發現該問題，這確實是我們的工作疏漏，對此我們深表歉意。”
Customer service staff at Posts & Telecom Press, the publishing house that released the guidebook, confirmed the quality issues, adding that anyone who purchased the book would be offered unconditional refunds. The publisher said the author failed to disclose the use of AI-generated images and that the problem was not identified during the editorial review process, calling it an internal oversight and apologizing for the lapse.
1月15日，中青報·中青網記者搜索發現，該出版社的多個購物平臺官方旗艦店已下架該書。
據了解，2025年9月1日起實施的《人工智能生成合成內容標識辦法》已經為AI生成內容的商業使用劃出紅線。其中明確要求，AI生成的圖片必須添加相關標識。中青報·中青網記者注意到，該問題書籍于2025年11月1日出版，但其AI生成圖片未進行任何標識，明顯不符合相關規定。
The case has also highlighted China's tightening oversight of AI-generated content. Rules that took effect in September 2025 require AI-generated images used for commercial purposes to be clearly labeled. However, despite being published after the rules came into force, the book carried no such disclosures, placing it in apparent violation of the requirements.
山東師范大學美術學院教授、博士生導師，山東省攝影家協會副主席聶勁權認為，“人像攝影書籍的核心價值是傳遞真實的拍攝經驗與光影把控技巧，但AI生成的圖片完全脫離真實拍攝場景，連基本的人體生理結構都出現錯誤，這是對讀者的誤導，更是對攝影專業的不尊重。”
Nie Jinquan, a professor at Shandong Normal University and vice-chairman of the Shandong Photographers Association, said the use of AI-generated images undermines the core purpose of photography textbooks.
"Photography books should reflect real shooting experience," he said. "AI images mislead readers and disrespect the profession."
對此，你怎么看？
來源：中國青年報 長江云新聞
跟著China Daily
精讀英語新聞
“無痛”學英語，每天20分鐘就夠！
特別聲明：以上內容(如有圖片或視頻亦包括在內)為自媒體平臺“網易號”用戶上傳并發布，本平臺僅提供信息存儲服務。
Notice: The content above (including the pictures and videos if any) is uploaded and posted by a user of NetEase Hao, which is a social media platform and only provides information storage services.
